The Science of Screaming
Karen Perta – karen.perta@elmhurst.edu
Instagram: @karenperta
Elmhurst University, Elmhurst, IL, 60126, United States
Zhaoyan Zhang, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA, United States.
Donna Erickson, Haskins Laboratories, New Haven, CT, United States.
Ryoko Hayashi, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan.
Toshiyuki Sadanobu, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan.
Popular version of 1pSC9 – Physiologic and acoustic characteristics of the angry scream
Presented at the 189th ASA Meeting
Read the abstract at https://eppro02.ativ.me/web/index.php?page=Session&project=ASAASJ25&id=3983050
–The research described in this Acoustics Lay Language Paper may not have yet been peer reviewed–
Most people can recall a day so bad that ended with screaming into a pillow. Emotional vocalization is a critical part of human communication. People scream when having fun at sporting events and theme parks, for safety, or to be heard in noisy environments. However, not all screaming and yelling is the same. Some may lose their voice after one night at a concert; others can protest on the picket lines for days without a problem. Why is this?
The purpose of this study is to analyze and compare angry, emotional screaming with trained, “healthy” yelling using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and acoustic measures. The MRI shows movements inside of the vocal tract so we can understand exactly how these sounds are created. In this study, a single vocally trained female participant produced angry screaming versus “healthy” belting. Here is a look inside the vocal tract during these sounds:
Figure 1. MRI images of Scream versus Belt (courtesy of authors).
Acoustic measures help characterize the differences between the sounds and provide further insight into how they are produced. Both MRI and acoustic analyses help determine the features that are harmful to the vocal folds versus the features that allow the voice to be heard safely. Here is a power spectrum view that shows frequency (x-axis) and intensity (y-axis) of the sounds as one snapshot in time:
Figure 2. Power spectrum of Scream versus Belt (courtesy of authors).
Based on the MRI measures, we determined that Scream was produced with 1) the highest position of the larynx 2) the largest mouth opening 3) the smallest throat space. Belt was produced with 1) a high larynx position though to a less extreme degree 2) a smaller mouth opening 3) more open space in the throat. Compared to Belt, Scream was also produced with an extremely high pitch – twice that of Belt.
During Scream, the tight throat space led to prolonged contact and strong compression of the vocal folds. This allowed Scream to produce higher intensity (stronger harmonic peaks in the spectrum) at high frequencies (above 6kHs) in Scream as compared to Belt. However, this high intensity production came at the cost of vocal fold injury. The Scream caused the participant to develop small vocal fold lesions that took about two weeks to resolve:
Figure 3. Participant vocal fold lesions following scream (courtesy of authors).
In conclusion, Scream is a primitive vocalization that is produced with a very constrictive action that is similar to swallowing. During swallowing, the vocal tract and vocal folds squeeze and compress in order to keep food and liquid from going into the airway. In contrast, Belt is a learned, trained behavior that is less constrictive and “overrides” innate tendencies for squeezing the vocal tract and pressing the vocal folds. During screaming, the highly constrictive actions of the vocal tract put extra strain and force on the vocal folds that contribute to vocal fold injury. Though it may take some practice, safe yelling should not be tight, feel painful, or cause voice loss. Use caution. Happy yelling!
Figure 1. MRI images of Scream versus Belt (courtesy of authors).
Figure 2. Power spectrum of Scream versus Belt (courtesy of authors).
Figure 3. Participant vocal fold lesions following scream (courtesy of authors).
It’s much easier to understand what others are saying if you’re listening to a close friend or family member, compared to a stranger. If you practice listening to the voices of people you’ve never met before, you might also become better at understanding them too.